News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Research by UNE scientist shows dogs thrive as vegetarians 

Research by UNE scientist shows dogs thrive as vegetarians

21 Dec, 2009 08:00 AM
ARMIDALE scientist Wendy Brown is at the centre of groundbreaking international research that has found that dogs can thrive on a meat-free diet.

Dr Brown was part of a team of scientists who monitored the health and performance of Siberian huskies over a 10-week sled-racing season.

They concluded that hard-working dogs can perform just as well on a meat-free diet as they do on a meat-rich diet.

Their results, published earlier this year in the British Journal of Nutrition (Vol 102, pp 1318-1323), add to the evidence that dogs fed an exclusively vegetarian diet can be just as healthy and happy as their meat-eating relatives.

Dr Brown, the canine nutritionist from the University of New England who led the husky trial, is confident that dogs can thrive on a meat-free diet.

She warns dog owners, however, that preparing an adequate vegetarian diet for a dog is more difficult and time-consuming than they might think.

Dr Brown has concerns, too, about some of the vegetarian dog foods that are becoming commercially available in growing numbers.

Many of these, she said, are untested.

“People manufacturing and buying vegetarian and vegan pet foods are often against testing, believing that even feeding trials are cruel,” she said.

“But feeding trials can be done in a friendly way. For my own trials, I borrow people’s pet dogs - some of them show dogs - and they are always well cared for. People visiting my kennels comment on how happy the dogs look. And they are.

“When I feed my own dogs, I want to know that what they’re eating is nutritionally adequate.

“As dogs belong to the order Carnivora, it’s often assumed that they are exclusively carnivorous, but in fact they are omnivores, belonging to the same superfamily within the Carnivora as the bamboo-eating giant panda and the omnivorous bear.”

In a paper presented at the University of New England during the international conference Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition 2009 and published in the conference proceedings, Dr Brown addresses the common argument that vegetarians should not impose their own values on their pets.

“A similar argument is often raised when human parents impose their religious or moral beliefs on their children, particularly when the belief system differs from that of the ethnic majority or predominant culture,” the paper says.

“In either case, it would be wise to assess the situation without prejudice.”

In the case of dogs, Dr Brown says, vegetarianism should be assessed purely from a nutritional perspective - i.e., whether the diet meets the dog’s nutritional needs, maintains the dog’s health, and is sufficiently enjoyable for the dog to eat enough of it.

Research has shown that vegetarian diets can meet these requirements, but that the preparation of a home-made vegetarian diet for a dog can be an exacting and time-consuming process.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Seriously, you have to be a fanatic to impose a vegetarian diet on a dog. Sorry folks, but death is a part of life and dogs are meat-eaters. Nothing cruel about it unless you consider the very nature of life cruel. We ALL live because something else dies. Buy your meat from local ranchers who let the animals eat grass and that will be your best contribution to making the world a more humane and healthy place.
Posted by dandilion, 21/12/2009 9:40:50 AM, on Armidale Express
My dog has been vegan (initially vegetarian) for over a year and has gone from a deadly illness (distemper) to being who he is now, a happy, healthy dog without any health or behavioral issues. I have done extensive research on canine nutrition and know that not only is my dog's diet adequate, but it is healthier and better for him, other animals and the planet as a result. I do agree with the article that it is time consuming initially, but it's like caring for a child, as a parent you must know what goes into your child's food, and how much of it he or she eats. No different with dogs. As for the argument that people "impose" any sort of diets, that's totally invalid. We take care of our dogs. Period. Whether we feed them meat or vegetarian based diets is no different if you're going to argue that we "impose" something upon them. Dogs have evolved over many years and are not strict meat eaters....
Posted by agrest, 22/12/2009 3:29:43 AM, on Armidale Express
Agree with what you say about the nature of life and making humane choices, however as it points out in the article, dogs are not pure carnivores, they are actually omnivores, and I suppose if it is possible to raise a happy and healthy dog on a veggie diet dog (albiet with a lot of extra work) then really there is nothing wrong with it and it's a lifestyle choice rather than fanaticism. I'm also sure that anyone choosing to feed their dog in this way (properly) would have a dog that's a damn site healthier than one fed on commercial tinned dog food full of additives and poor quality meat, and unfortunately there are a lot of dogs out there that are fed like that. There is a saying 'put your money into the food that goes onto the table or you might as well give it to the chemist/doctor' Truer words were never spoken, but the same goes for our pets too.
Posted by Satana, 22/12/2009 5:44:42 AM, on Armidale Express
Why do you have to be a fanatic? Because I don't want to feed my dogs rotting flesh and who knows what else (that go into bags of commercial dog food), I'm a fanatic? And I bet it's very convenient for everyone to buy their "meat" from a local rancher too! Dogs are perfectly healthy on nutritionally balanced vegetarian diets. That's humane!
Posted by jamberry, 23/12/2009 4:27:03 AM, on Armidale Express
There's no reason why dogs can't live healthily on a vegan diet if it is balanced and has all the nutrients it needs. However, once a dog is accustomed to meat and bones, it shouldn't be forced to abandon and change the diet too fast, or completely. I am a vegan and our family eats mainly vegan food, however, our two dogs still get cans of meat. Considering that dogs are omnivores, it is reasonable that meat is not essential but optional. Unfortunately, vegan dog food is expensive.
Posted by Vivienne, 24/12/2009 8:49:31 PM, on Armidale Express
Why should we push our belief on dogs that they HAVE to eat meat? Dogs can be healthy and happy on vegan diet. My 5 dogs are. In fact they are healthier than meat eating dogs, even those who are younger. I don't think that death is part of life. Death is the end of life, and animals, whom we kill for our beliefs, value their life just like we do and are terrified of death just like we are, even those of us who might say that there is nothing cruel about (somebody else's) death.
Posted by Lidia, 1/01/2010 1:52:10 AM, on Armidale Express
Please can we have the formula (for home cooked animal and planetary friendly dog food)? I want very much to feed my dog (and cat) vegan.
Posted by Amelia, 3/01/2010 11:57:32 PM, on Armidale Express
I think this is a very controversial topic... If a dog is born and raised vegan and/or vegetarian, and the dog doesn't mind the food, then it's fine! Who gives a rats if its natural or not, low quality people food in a can is CERTAINLY not good to give to a dog! If your dog has already been eating canned food/meat diet for years, switching over wouldn't be fair to the dog, so just start buying expensive meat and give it to them raw. That is very good for them..but I suggest meat from whole foods. Or private farm. dandilion, I agree with what you are saying, but you have to put thought into it and try it out! These people here are only trying to make the environment and the world we live on a better place. And does anyone know if canned dog food is raw? Because guess what? Its off the bat not great for a dog, dogs should be eating raw meat.
Posted by Carly, 4/01/2010 12:07:56 AM, on Armidale Express
This research just confirms what vegetarian pet owners have known for years. My dog was adopted as sickly, malnourished and emotionally drained but is now a well-adjusted, outgoing and energetic vegan dog. Seeing how positively the diet worked for her inspired my partner to go vegan too! It is frightening that even supposed veterinarians still make the mistake of believing dogs are carnivores, when they are so clearly not.
Posted by Joanne, 4/01/2010 10:29:43 AM, on Armidale Express
Yes, it's possible for a dog to survive on a plant-based diet *if* that diet is highly processed. The fact remains that dogs are unable to crush plant matter the way that animals with grinding teeth and side-to-side jaw motion can and that they do not have the digestive capability to break down most plant matter in its raw state. This is why these vegetarian foods must be cooked/ground/pulped/supplemented /etc. and why the dogs cannot live off of them otherwise. Do I want my dog to live on a highly processed diet or do I want my dog to live on a diet consisting of whole raw foods with all of their God-given nutrients intact? I know my choice.
Posted by Victor, 12/01/2010 3:34:16 AM, on Armidale Express
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
UNE researcher Wendy Brown believes dogs can thrive on a meat-free diet
UNE researcher Wendy Brown believes dogs can thrive on a meat-free diet

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 6%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

click to go to photo gallery
 
Subscribe to the Armidale Express Home Delivery
 
Find Armidale Real Estate Agents


Armidale Express







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...